Darknet crypto: why markets moved from Bitcoin to Monero, and what mixers do
Updated
Darknet markets run on crypto because it lets a buyer pay a stranger without a bank. For the first decade that meant Bitcoin. But every Bitcoin payment sits on a public ledger, and once analytics firms and police learned to follow it from market wallets to exchange accounts, the markets started moving to Monero, which hides the sender, the receiver, and the amount by default. Mixers, also called tumblers, are the older answer to the same problem: they pool coins from many users so a single payment is harder to follow. Neither one removes the step where coins become ordinary money, and that step is where most cases are built.
Why Bitcoin came first, and why it became a liability
A darknet market needs a way to pay that does not require the buyer and the vendor to share a name, a card, or a bank. In 2011 the only thing that did that was Bitcoin. Silk Road ran on it from the start, and by the FBI’s count the market handled about $1.2 billion in sales before it was seized in 2013. Every market that followed for the next several years took Bitcoin, and most took nothing else.
The weakness was built in. Bitcoin does not record names, but it records everything else: which address paid which, how much, and when, in a ledger anyone can download. Addresses that are reused, or combined in one payment, can be grouped into clusters that belong to one person or one service. Follow a cluster long enough and it usually ends at an exchange, which can be asked for the account holder’s identity. Blockchain analytics became an industry on exactly that work. When Treasury sanctioned the Russian market Hydra in April 2022, it put the market’s crypto income at about $5.2 billion, a figure only possible because the payments were public.
A vendor who reuses an address, consolidates payments into one wallet, and eventually sells coins on an exchange is laying out the evidence step by step. That is the reason markets started moving away from Bitcoin, beginning in the late 2010s and speeding up after the big 2017 seizures.
Today the large markets split into three groups. Some are Monero-only: DrugHub, which inherited the rule from White House Market, and DarkMatter until its exit scam in September 2026. Archetyp, taken down in 2025, took only Monero as well, according to the German indictment. Some take both, like Torzon. And some have gone the other way: Black Ops added Bitcoin in April 2026 to reach buyers who find Monero too hard to buy.
What Bitcoin and Monero each show an observer
| What an observer can see | Bitcoin | Monero |
|---|---|---|
| Who sent | The sending address, which can be grouped with others into a cluster | A group of possible senders; an outsider cannot tell which one actually paid |
| Who received | The receiving address, which stays the same if it is reused | A one-time address; the recipient’s published wallet address never appears on the chain |
| How much | The exact amount, on every payment | Hidden, on every payment, since 2017 |
| What privacy takes | Extra tools and discipline: mixers, CoinJoin, never reusing addresses | Nothing extra; it is the default |
| What remains after the chain | The exchange account where coins become money | The same exchange account, plus any swap back to Bitcoin on the way there |
The two coins differ completely on what the ledger shows, and not at all on where the money ends up. How the money moves inside the market itself, through escrow and commissions, is on the darknet economy page.
What Monero hides, and where that stops
Monero launched in April 2014 from an earlier codebase called CryptoNote, with no coins set aside for its founders. The project describes itself as “secure, private, untraceable,” and it builds that privacy into every transaction rather than offering it as an option. Three techniques do most of the work.
Ring signatures hide the sender. Each payment is signed by a group made of the real coin plus decoys pulled from the blockchain, and an outsider cannot tell which member of the group actually spent. Stealth addresses hide the recipient: the sender’s wallet creates a fresh one-time address for every payment, so payments cannot be linked to the recipient’s public address or to each other. RingCT hides the amount, and has been mandatory since September 2017.
“Untraceable” is true in a narrow sense: an outsider looking only at Monero’s blockchain cannot follow a payment the way they can on Bitcoin. The popular version, that Monero makes darknet trading impossible to trace, is wrong. Police have made arrests in cases where Monero was the market’s currency, including Archetyp. Weaknesses in how Monero picked decoys have made some older transactions easier to trace. Many vendors swap Monero back to Bitcoin to sell it, which creates exactly the link Monero was meant to avoid. And the final sale to an exchange leaves a record no matter which coin was used on the market.
The price of that privacy is access. Major exchanges have dropped Monero under pressure from regulators, Binance in February 2024 among them, so buying it now takes more steps than buying Bitcoin. That is the trade-off behind every market’s coin choice: Monero-only markets trade a smaller audience for less evidence on the chain.
How crypto mixers work: three designs
A mixer takes coins from many users, pools them, and pays each user back the same value minus a fee, from different coins. The goal is to break the simple link between “this deposit” and “that withdrawal.” Mixer and tumbler are two words for the same thing. There are three designs, and they fail in different ways.
- Centralized, or custodial
- You send coins to an operator, who holds a pool, waits, varies the amounts and timing, and sends other coins to the address you gave. Bitcoin Fog and Blender.io worked this way. You have to trust the operator with your coins in the meantime. The Secret Service’s May 2025 advisory spells out the risk: the operator can disappear with the deposits, and may keep logs, including IP addresses, that investigators can later obtain. It is the same problem as pooled escrow on a market.
- CoinJoin
- Several Bitcoin users build one shared transaction with many inputs and many outputs of equal size, so an observer cannot tell which input paid which output. Each user keeps control of their coins throughout. Wasabi Wallet and Samourai Wallet’s Whirlpool were the best-known versions. The equal-sized outputs make CoinJoin transactions easy to spot, even when the individual paths are hard to prove.
- Smart-contract mixers
- Code on a blockchain, usually Ethereum, holds the pool. You deposit a fixed amount, get a secret note, and later withdraw to a new address with a cryptographic proof that you are owed a withdrawal, without revealing which deposit was yours. Tornado Cash is the standard example. There is no operator holding the coins, but there is still a website to take down, a contract address to sanction, and developers to charge.
None of the three erases the trail. The amounts and timing of deposits and withdrawals, what the user did before and after, and where the coins finally went are all still visible. And every design has its own failure: a centralized operator can steal the pool or hand over logs, a CoinJoin is easy to flag, and a contract can be sanctioned so that touching it becomes a legal problem.
What the U.S. government has done about mixers
Since 2022, U.S. authorities have sanctioned mixers, charged their founders, and been partly overruled in court. None of these actions says that using a mixer is always a crime. Several of them show that running one, or dealing with a sanctioned one, is treated as a serious federal matter.
| When | Who | What happened |
|---|---|---|
| 6 May 2022 | Treasury (OFAC) | Blender.io sanctioned, the first mixer Treasury ever designated. It had moved more than $500 million since 2017, including over $20.5 million from the March 2022 Axie Infinity hack attributed to North Korea’s Lazarus Group. |
| 8 August 2022 | Treasury (OFAC) | Tornado Cash sanctioned. More than $7 billion had passed through it since 2019, including over $455 million stolen by Lazarus. U.S. persons were barred from dealing with it. Treasury re-designated it on 8 November 2022. |
| 29 November 2023 | Treasury (OFAC) | Sinbad.io sanctioned. Treasury called it Lazarus’s preferred mixer after Blender and the likely successor to it, used on proceeds from the Atomic Wallet, Axie Infinity, and Horizon Bridge thefts. |
| November 2024 | Fifth Circuit | In Van Loon v. Department of the Treasury, the appeals court ruled that Tornado Cash’s immutable smart contracts are not “property” that can be sanctioned under the law Treasury used. |
| 21 March 2025 | Treasury | Tornado Cash removed from the sanctions list. Treasury did not accept the court’s reasoning; it said it had reviewed “novel legal and policy issues” and used its discretion, and kept warning about North Korean use of such services. |
| May 2025 | Secret Service | Public advisory on mixers, explaining the main types and stating that operating a mixer while knowing it processes illicit funds is a crime. It also lists the January 2025 charges against the alleged operators of Blender and Sinbad. |
| 19 November 2025 | Southern District of New York | Samourai Wallet’s founders sentenced to five and four years. Prosecutors said its Whirlpool and Ricochet services moved more than 80,000 BTC, worth over $2 billion at the time, and that the founders knowingly moved more than $237 million in criminal proceeds, including from darknet markets. |
The criminal cases fill in the rest. Roman Sterlingov was found guilty of running Bitcoin Fog in March 2024 and sentenced that November to twelve and a half years. In the Netherlands, Tornado Cash developer Alexey Pertsev was convicted of money laundering in May 2024 and sentenced to more than five years, and appealed. In the United States, a jury in August 2025 convicted Tornado Cash co-founder Roman Storm of conspiring to run an unlicensed money-transmitting business, but could not agree on the money-laundering and sanctions charges.
Tornado Cash went onto the sanctions list and came off it. Samourai’s founders went to prison for a CoinJoin service that, according to prosecutors, they marketed for cleaning criminal coins. Courts have limited what Treasury can sanction, while juries have convicted the people who built and ran mixers.
What “no KYC” and “no AML” crypto exchanges are selling
KYC, or Know Your Customer, is an exchange checking who you are before it holds or converts your coins. AML, anti-money laundering, is the program that flags coins that look like criminal proceeds, including coins that came from mixers or darknet markets. A service advertised as “no KYC” or “no AML” sells the absence of both: a swap between coins, often reachable over Tor, that asks for no ID and promises the coins coming out cannot be tied to the coins going in.
The label has no legal effect. Under U.S. law, mixing services that act as money transmitters have the same registration and reporting duties as any other, and FinCEN fined one mixer operator $60 million in 2020 for ignoring them, as Treasury noted when it sanctioned Tornado Cash. Whether a particular customer broke the law by using such a swap depends on the country, the service, and what they knew. Whether the swap itself is legal does not depend on what its homepage says.
What the pitch leaves out is that the swap is only a middle step. Trading Bitcoin for Monero, or Monero for Bitcoin, moves coins between chains; it does not turn them into rent money. That still happens at a regulated exchange, with a KYC file, and a “no AML” label on the step before does not change what that exchange sees.
Cashing out is where most cases start
Crypto from a darknet market is only useful once it becomes ordinary money. For almost everyone, that means selling it on a regulated exchange that knows its customers and must report suspicious deposits. That moment, much more than the market itself, is where investigators build cases against vendors.
Operation RapTor, announced by the Justice Department in May 2025, is the recent example: 270 arrests in ten countries, most of them vendors rather than market operators, and more than $200 million in cash and crypto seized. The markets those vendors used had been shut down years earlier; the cases against the people came later, built on seized databases and on the money that had left the markets since.
That is why a market switching to Monero did not put investigators out of work. It made the on-chain part much harder and left the cash-out where it was.
How fake mixers and fake swaps steal
A real centralized mixer already holds your coins for a while and can steal them. A fake mixer is a site built to do nothing else. The pattern is the same as the phishing copies of markets described on the darknet markets page.
- The lookalike
- A clearnet site borrowing the name of a known mixer or swap service, often with the word “official,” that asks for a deposit first. Its only job is to receive coins. It will show a convincing progress screen and never pay out.
- The custodial vanish
- Even a mixer that started out honest can leave with its pool, and the Secret Service advisory warns that operators can do so at any time. Mixers that shut down in the middle of a busy period take every pending deposit with them.
- The swap that is only a form
- A “no AML Tor exchange” with no named company, no published terms, and nothing about how it works beyond a deposit address and a promised rate. Some are unlicensed swap desks. Many are just a wallet with a website on top. From the outside, the two look the same until the coins fail to arrive.
The common sign is that the site wants your coins before it shows you anything you could check. A CoinJoin can be inspected on the blockchain, and a smart-contract mixer has a published contract address. A page with a QR code and the words “instant, anonymous, no logs” has nothing to inspect.
Mixer legality and Bitcoin: two common questions
Is using a crypto mixer illegal?
Not automatically. It depends on the country, the specific mixer, and the purpose. In the United States, dealing with a sanctioned mixer is prohibited for U.S. persons regardless of intent, and Blender.io and Sinbad.io are still on the sanctions list. Operating a mixer while knowing it launders criminal money is a crime, which is what Samourai’s founders were sentenced for. Using a mixer to hide criminal proceeds is money laundering in most countries, whatever the mixer is.
Why do some markets still take Bitcoin?
Because buyers have it. Bitcoin is on every exchange and in every wallet, while Monero has been delisted from many of the largest exchanges, and each extra step to buy a coin loses customers. Markets that take both let users choose between convenience and privacy. Markets that added Bitcoin later, like Black Ops in April 2026, chose a bigger audience over safer payments.
How we know this
Sanctions, charges, and sentences on this page come from U.S. Treasury, Justice Department, and Secret Service notices linked in the text, and Monero’s privacy features are described as the Monero project describes them. What no-KYC swap services promise is taken from how they present themselves; we have not used a mixer or a swap service, and none is recommended here. Our editorial standards explain how we label claims.